PML-N leaders deplore dismissal of Panama petitions by SC

By GEO NEWS
September 15, 2017

Barrister Zaffarullah says it is not the end of the world; Saad Rafique said they didn't have much hope from the review petitions

Saad Rafique addressing the press conference. Photo: Geo News

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) leader and federal railways minister, Khawaja Saad Rafique said on Friday that the government had an idea of today's decision of the Supreme Court but they still decided to go for a review.

Addressing the media in Islamabad, he said the PML-N is the country’s biggest and mature political party which does not wish to seek a clash among state institutions.

Referring to the recent bench-bar row in Multan, he said the government protected the judiciary after the agitation from lawyers, which is its duty.

"We don’t want anyone to repeat their mistakes, including us," he said, adding that in an atmosphere where a US president makes such dangerous remarks the country needs to stand united.

He requested political workers of all parties to consider Sunday's by-election in NA-120 as just an 'election' and nothing more. "We need to tolerate each other with patience and just let the people decide on," he suggested.

Rafique, a veteran PML-N worker and MNA from Lahore, congratulated Maryam Nawaz for running a successful campaign for mother Kulsoom, the party's candidate in NA-120.

No review of our review: Talal Chaudhry

Meanwhile, State Interior Minister Talal Chaudhry said the Supreme Court did not evaluate the pleas against the Panama Papers case judgment.

Talal Chaudhry

Speaking to Geo News soon after the court dismissed all the review petitions filed by Nawaz Sharif, his children, son-in-law, and Finance Minister Ishaq Dar, Chaudhry said, "no review was carried out of our review petition".

"All our main points regarding theright to a free trial were not considered," he said, adding that the party will decide on its legal and political options after consultation.

"We are seeking a review of the country's judicial system and talking about a 'grand national dialogue' because if a prime minister cannot get justice then how can a common person," he remarked.

Anusha Rehman

Addressing a press conference later, State IT Minister Anusha Rehman said the dismissal of review petitions is astonishing.

"The honourable bench assured us during the last three days that our rights will be protected at all costs but, while dismissing the references, the bench has not mentioned any such thing," she lamented.

We are concerned that if a monitoring judge, who has ruled against us, remains on top of the case it will influence thelower court, she added.

'Not end of the world'

Barrister Zafarullah, the prime minister's special assistant, said the party has faith in the Constitution and the system.

He said the dismissal of their review petitions is not the end of the world.

"This decision is similar to the one in the Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, Zafar Ali Shah and Maulvi Tameezuddin cases. History and people will decide on its merit," he said, adding that "we are not anarchists".

Barrister Zafarullah

Zaffarullah said they are a democratic party and thus accept the verdict.

Sharing his party's plans to "improve thesystem", he said they will push the bill, already in Parliament, to place a right of appeal in cases taken up by the apex court under Article 184(3).

In response to a question, he said a judge of the Lahore High Court was also named in the Panama Papers and wondered why a case is not being pursued against him.

Zaffarullah and Rehman both claimed that there is not a single example where the Supreme Court appointed a monitoring judge for a case such as this one.

Review petitions dismissed

Earlier today, the five-member bench of the Supreme Court dismissed all review pleas after the petitioners' counsels wrapped up their arguments earlier.

The Supreme Court's judgment in the Panama Papers case had resulted in then premier Nawaz Sharif's disqualification and filing of monitored and time bound corruption cases against them.

Reading out the short-order, Justice Asif Saeed Khosa, who headed the five-member bench, remarked that the court will share reasons for dismissal of the petitions later.

The bench was headed by Justice Khosa and comprised Justice Gulzar Ahmed, Justice Ijazul Ahsan, Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed and Justice Ejaz Afzal Khan — who along with the latter two headed the special implementation bench in the Panama case that oversaw the work of the Joint Investigation Team.

The bench began hearing the petitions on Wednesday after it was decided a day earlier to approve the Sharif family's plea for the formation of a larger bench to hear the petitions rather than the earlier notified three-member bench.

After today's decision, the Sharif family and Dar will have to seek justice in the Islamabad Accountability Court, where three references against the Sharif family and one against the finance minister have been filed.

Members of the Sharif family have been summoned by the accountability court on September 19 and Dar on September 20.


Next Story >>>
Advertisement

More From Pakistan